The Boy Next Door by Kate McMurray (2nd Edition) Dual Review

Title: The Boy Next Door (2nd Edition)

Author: Kate McMurray

Genre: Contemporary

Length: Novel (200 pages)

Publisher: Dreamspinner Press (22 July 2016)

Heat Level: Moderate

Heart Rating: ♥♥♥♥♥ 4 Hearts (Combined)

Blurb: Life is full of surprises and, with luck, second chances.

After his father’s death, Lowell leaves the big city to help his sick mother in the conservative small town where he grew up. He’s shocked to find himself living next to none other than his childhood friend Jase. Lowell always had a crush on Jase, and the man has only gotten more attractive with age. Unfortunately Jase is straight, now divorced, and raising his six-year-old daughter. It’s nice to reconnect, but Lowell doesn’t see a chance for anything beyond friendship.

Until a night out together changes everything.

Jase can’t fight his growing feelings for Lowell, and he doesn’t want to give up the happy future they could have. But his ex-wife issues an ultimatum: he must keep his homosexuality secret or she’ll revoke his custody of their daughter, Layla. Now Jase faces an impossible choice: Lowell and the love he’s always wanted, or his daughter.

ISBN: 978-1-63477-382-9

Product Link: Dreamspinner Press | Amazon US | Amazon UK

Reviewer: Prime & Lisa

Prime’s Review: ♥♥♥♥♥ 5 Hearts

Kate McMurray is one of those authors where I like to check out the blurb of a new (to me) book and is slowly becoming a definite favorite on my ever growing list of favorite authors. She does sweet and heartwarming romances for the most part. They are the type of thing that you sit down with your book/device and just pass your time pleasantly reading the extraordinarily sweet characters that emerge from her very ordinary and very relatable world.

The Boy Next Door is a second edition, of which I did not read the first edition so not sure what has changed. It is about Lowell who goes back to his hometown to care for his mother, who seems to be getting rather forgetful, after the death of his father. His father was not a kind man in life and so in death his ghost does affect his relationship with both his mother and the town. The surprise Lowell gets though is that his new neighbor is Jase. They were friends as children and as teens Lowell had had a massive crush on Jase.

Jase seems to be very straight. The evidence is still there with his recent divorce and a little girl dominating most of his time and thoughts. But Jase has a massive secret and sees the strength in the out of the closet Lowell – he’s gay, has known all his life but has tried for many years to hide that part of himself. With Lowell’s return Jase has got to confront his feelings and the manipulative people in his life if he wants a quick hook up with his friend to be a lot more.

The chemistry between these two guys is great. There is a certain depth of emotion that makes it so easy to not only relate to both Lowell and Jase, but to see that the thick sexual tension between them is more than a fling. I really liked the drama that happens between the guys – it goes to add to the feeling that certain people in Jase’s life are not only homophobic but manipulative as well. It adds a lot of depth to Jase’s character.

This book lived up to my expectations; ultimately, it was a sweet and heartwarming romance that worked on all levels.

Lisa’s Review ♥♥♥ 3 Hearts

Lowell and Jase were friends when they were children but grew apart once they were in high school.  Now several years later there is a chance to rebuild that friendship. Lowell has moved back home to help his mother.  He just happens to live next door to Jase.

Jase is raising his daughter, while dealing with his bitch of an ex who is threatening to keep him away from his kid.  As long as no one knows that he likes men, then there will be no problems.  Well there is a big problem, he wants his old friend.

Now the story is like real life for some men.  However it didn’t do anything for me.  The story had no appeal for me and I had trouble keeping my attention on it.  The characters were pretty good with enough depth to make them stand out.  Even the fighting is pretty real throughout the story but that is about all there was to it.  The ending was a bit off and I had trouble connecting the two together.

Jase has enough guilt to drown the whole town.  He feels responsible for everyone and everything.  His ex-wife is a bitter bitch who wants to control him.  He is nasty sometimes to Lowell, and if I was Lowell I would just kick his ass to the curb.  To top it off Lowell comes off as a wimp to me.  I could not connect with either character.  Which was a depressing thought.

I was left with more questions then answers with this story.  Also there was just something about the way the story was wrote that reminded me of a newbie just starting out.  I mean what was with the short statements and crazy questions that one finds in this book.  So basically this is one of those stories that I skimmed through because I just couldn’t get into it at all.  I am afraid that this was one book that was just not for me.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.